It happened the first time about a month after their return. Scully awoke from one of her more harrowing nightmares, to hear an echoing scream dying away downstairs. Since their return from the west, she had dropped all pretense of maintaining a strictly professorial relationship with the boy, and he had all but moved in. She had even gone so far as to offer him one of the guest rooms as his own, but he showed a marked preference for the sofa in her study. It was from there that the scream had come. She hurried down the stairs in the predawn darkness, calling out breathlessly for the lights as she went. He was sitting up when she arrived, holding his head in his hands and breathing heavily, covered with a fine sheen of sweat. He started when she touched his shoulder, then recognizing her, fell back heavily against the sofa, his eyes closed. "I'm sorry I woke you," he apologized. "It was just a dream." "Do you want to talk about it?" she asked, sympathetically. He cracked his eyes slightly, peering at her from under the lids. "I think maybe we've talked about it too much already. It was a lot like the dreams you've described to me. I think maybe I'm not old enough for scary bedtime stories," he cracked. Smiling slightly at his attempt at levity, she encouraged, "Tell me anyway." So he did, and as his tale progressed, Scully's expression grew tighter and more guarded. "And then, everybody that was with us started to, I don't know, dissolve. There was a gas, it stung my eyes and I couldn't breathe. I reached for you, but there was a man, he'd already gotten to you, and I couldn't move because of the gas. He took your hand, and you both stood up and turned toward me. You were fine, the gas didn't seem to be affecting you anymore, and you came over to me, and he looked down and said, 'You're part of this, you can stop it. Don't fail her, son.'" Scully breathed the word with him. Son. "And then he reached down to me, too, and suddenly I could breathe again, but just as I got my breath something came behind you both, a thick black ooze, not even light reflected from it and it enveloped you and all I could do with the breath was scream." He sank deeper into the sofa, spent with the telling of the tale. They sat that way, still and quiet, for long moments, while Scully debated with herself whether to address the most astonishing aspect of his dream. At last he broke her reverie asking, "It means something, doesn't it? What aren't you telling me?" Since she had come to recognize the echo of Mulder in his hazel eyes, she had stopped being able to keep any truth from him. "I don't know what it means, David, any more this dream than the ones before it. But I know one thing, and that is that it wasn't your dream. It was mine." She paused, letting the revelation sink in. "Image for image, event for event, you described the dream that woke me, just in time to hear your scream." "Weird," finally, was all he said. ------------------------------------------------------------- The research had continued apace when they had returned. Scully was distracted by her efforts to determine the overall level of immunity of the population, and spent hours each day mining the huge database of genetic data that existed on the population, gathered routinely as part of almost any medical procedure. While the benefits to medical research of such information gathering were indisputable, to Scully, the practice seemed nearly as invasive as the trackers. And yet she had no better recourse than to deny her own sense of ethics for what she believed was a greater good. It seemed it had always been this way. If she were to be denied death, she wished at least for a life where she no longer had to make these choices. Outright immunity to the virus was indeed at an all time low, but there were unmistakable genetic changes in the population at large that could clearly be traced to modifications introduced by the original vaccine. They were subtle changes, nothing likely to be recognized without foreknowledge of what had been done. At the time, they hadn't expected the treatment to prove particularly heritable, although they had expected it to affect fetuses in utero at the time of the inoculation. She was frustrated by the scale of the task in front of her. There wasn't anywhere near the kind of time available, if her ever present sense of foreboding was to be trusted, to isolate family lineages, trace the changes, and try to understand them. It wasn't even clear if the changes were meaningful, or merely a remnant, since they tended to be found on intergenic regions that weren't well studied. She kept David focused entirely on their continuing research of the expanded Gray DNA, sensing instinctively, and reinforced by vivid dreaming, that gaining a fundamental understanding of their essential nature would be critical to withstand whatever was coming. Tiring, for the moment, of her own investigations, she decided to join David at his console to check his progress. "I'm almost done," he said, sensing her attention. "You know, that's getting a little creepy," she commented, "the way you always seem to know when I'm about to check on you." He shrugged. "We've been in this lab together for a year, now. I'm just getting to know your habits." He pinched the bridge of his nose and stretched while she crossed the room to join him. "Another headache?" she asked, concerned. He'd been complaining of them steadily since the night they had shared her dream. He was working too hard, they both were. "Maybe you should take a break. You haven't gone for a run in a long time. It might make you feel better." He shook his head. "No, but thanks for offering. Actually, it's usually better here. It seems to get worse when I'm out in a crowd. The noise, all the chatter, really seems to get to me. It's quieter here." Dropping the subject he turned back to his console. "Look here, it's not quite complete, but it's very revealing." Together, they looked over the findings. Based on the strange triumvirate of major systems they had discovered the previous trimester, and the fact that in most cases, at least one of the three bore a striking resemblance to the human genome, David had been attempting to discover if a complete human-like genome could be isolated out of the expanded Gray DNA. It was eighty five percent complete, and the results were surprising. "Look at what I've found here," he said, bringing up a long section of code related to blood chemistry. "This," he pointed, "looks incompatible with our blood chemistry. Toxic, even." He shook his head. "I wish I knew what this meant. This genome describes something that is so nearly humanoid, and yet the differences are so perplexing. I keep worrying that I've accidentally pulled in data from one of the other two apparent species." "Well, it's possible, but I think you've been as thorough and careful as possible. I think your feel for differentiating between the three has surpassed my own, at this point, so I won't second guess you." Reaching around him, she touched the controls that brought up the overview of the recognizable biological systems he had mapped. "Still nothing on reproduction?" she asked, surprised. "Not much," he confirmed. "What little I've found all seems to correlate loosely to what we'd consider male. Mechanisms for donating genetic material, but nothing for gestating it." He shrugged. "It could simply be that the original sample we're working from is some sort of male. Or it could be that the female information is in the parts I haven't mapped yet. Or..." he drifted off, considering. "We don't yet have an understanding of why this DNA describes three species, unless it *is* some sort of colonial, like you originally suggested. So maybe the gestational aspect is in one of the other two species." Scully was impressed by the theoretical leaps he was willing to consider, the growth he had shown since that long ago evening when he'd flatly denied the possibility of a shape shifting man with a tail. She began a compliment, the words forming on the tip of her tongue, when she was interrupted by growling complaint of her stomach. "I don't know," David said absently, already reabsorbed in the console display. "Don't know what?" Scully asked. "Where Jerry is. You just asked." Scully shook her head. Had she said that aloud? She didn't think so, although she had certainly thought it. Jerry usually fixed dinner when he was around. "I'll be in the kitchen," she said thoughtfully. ------------------------------------------------------------- It went from weird, to uncanny, to undeniable. He sensed her thoughts. They came painlessly now, and with clarity, and he did his best to learn how not to eavesdrop. The price of knowing her thoughts included knowing exactly how uncomfortable that knowledge made her. In public it was harder. A large group presented a resounding din in his head. Here, the headaches were everpresent. Focusing down to a single voice, or filtering the noise from his head altogether, exhausted him. He learned by necessity, now more than ever keeping up the appearance of normalcy at the university seemed paramount, but his lab sections depleted him, and Scully went back to handling most of the lectures. She'd told him of her long past but rare experiences with human telepathy. The child, Gibson Praise, who had been born with the ability and seemed to bear it with no ill-effect other than the melancholy of knowing hypocrisy at far too young an age. Mulder's transformation, which had almost killed him before an un-consented to operation removed both the threat and the potential. He knew she was concerned lest his own transformation prove life-threatening, and she monitored his progress closely, watching for signs of brain damage and trying to understand the catalyst to the changes. They suspected some interaction between his modern physiology, bearing the genetic remnants of the original vaccine, and his recent direct re-exposure, but had little time to seek proof. Generally, Scully's house was a sufficiently quiet retreat to let him rest, but thoughts accompanied by strong emotion carried loudly, and the school's heavily attended athletic events always kept him awake. Gradually, he learned that he could hear a familiar 'voice', even at a distance, if he concentrated. He missed Jerry's soothing presence. Jerry's mind didn't intrude onto his own, and he found it relaxing to have a conversation in the strictly verbal sense. He wasn't sure why it was so, but assumed that their different species must be at the heart the matter. Perhaps it was like broadcasting on a frequency that David couldn't tune to. Jerry's absences seemed to last longer and longer, and he never accepted Scully's invitations to her home anymore. The last time David had seen Jerry had been a week ago, when he'd gone back to his campus housing to collect some clean clothes and water his one frail but tenacious jade plant. David was surprised to feel an unfamiliar buzzing in his head, and complained about the new voice. Jerry hadn't reacted, other than to say he was going west for a few weeks, to help Nana with some work on the ranch. Such visits were unremarkable, there was always something to be done on a ranch, except that this time of year was the quiet time, and it hardly seemed necessary. He fretted for a while that Jerry and Scully harbored some discord of which he'd been kept ignorant, and later fretted that he'd done something himself to offend his friend. Neither explanation seemed likely, though, and he finally convinced himself that Jerry just missed Nana, that was all. As he became accustomed to his new talent, he found it had benefits, as well. He'd long since come to relish his duties as a teaching assistant. He connected well with his students in the lab, and had a flair for breaking down difficult and obscure concepts, presenting them in clear, manageable chunks that allowed most of his students the sense of accomplishment that comes from drawing the correct conclusion. Now, a furrowed brow in the third row conveyed more than the fact that a student was struggling to make the connection. A quick peek was all it took understand the precise source of the confusion, and address it. At first he worried whether it was ethical to peek in their minds without their knowledge, but he rationalized that he was only intruding on thoughts whose topic was a matter of public record, as demonstrated by their being in the class. And it helped everyone. His students would pass their term exams well out in front of the average, while he honed his control at listening, and filtering. And if he couldn't help but overhear the romantic daydreams of Amy, the slight, brown- haired girl in the second row with the secretive smile, well, that was kind of his business too, since they were centered on him. For the first time in close to a year, he chafed at his responsibilities to Dr. Charles', Scully's, research. He wasn't old and he wasn't dead. He'd ask the girl out if he weren't so busy. That feeling always abated when he was absorbed in his research. He had begun trying to isolate out the other two species from one another, and was particularly interested in trying to discover what reproductive interactivity there might be between the three. He never did find time to ask Amy out, but though he felt guilty about it, when he fell into bed each night, spent from his hours at the console, he would seek out her mind, and eavesdrop on the ridiculously flattering fantasies of himself that she sent herself to sleep with. ------------------------------------------------------------- Scully awoke from dreaming with the most profound sense of dread she had yet experienced. Odd, because nothing had happened in the dream to speak of. There were no grisly plagues, no holocausts, no teeming masses hurrying to their deaths. Just Mulder, floating in a brilliant white light, and three words. "It has begun." She arrived at her office that morning to find an urgent message from the dean regarding one of the school's students. Faculty: Please assist local authorities as needed in determining the last known whereabouts of a South Eastern University student. She has been reported missing by her parents, with whom she resides locally. According to her parents, she has failed to return home for two nights, without advising them of her whereabouts, which is a departure from her usual behavior. Concern for her safety has arisen, as a routine tracking request appears to have uncovered that the girl carries a malfunctioning tracker unit, placing her last known position in Africa, and failing to return any biodata. Your cooperation is appreciated. The message ended with an image of the girl and her vital statistics, and had been sent to every professor with whom she had a course. David arrived while she was checking attendance records, trying to recall if she had actually seen the girl at her last lecture. "Do you know Amy Richardson?" she asked. "Not really," he answered, too quickly. "I mean, yeah, she's in the Wednesday lab, but, uh, y'know," he fidgeted, "I don't really *know her* know her, she's just a student." Scully gazed up at him, her lips lightly pursed, puzzled by his stammering performance. "I never said she wasn't. Can you remember the last time you had contact with her?" she asked. "Contact?" he repeated, "How do you mean?" She cocked her head at the non-sequitur response. "Did she attend your last lab? Come for extra help to office hours?" she gave as examples, eyebrows raised. "How else would I mean?" Misreading his blush, she jumped to the obvious conclusion, and sat back with an indulgent smile. "Have you been seeing her, David? How ever did you find the time?" "No!" he exclaimed. Then, more calmly, "No, I mean, I'd like to, but I've been too busy." A crush, then, maybe, Scully thought. Except that he was behaving awfully adolescently about it. "Why are you asking about her? She hasn't complained, or something, has she?" "No, she's missing. What would she have to complain about, David?" He grimaced, realizing his tactical error. The question had been too revealing. As nonchalantly as possible, he seated himself before answering, "Nothing that I can think of. How long has she been gone?" "Two days." She paused, wondering if he would volunteer any information, but he simply nodded, schooling his expression to one of superficial concern. She pressed him. "David, you're acting bizarre. What do you know about this girl?" "Nothing! Really. I don't know where she is. Why aren't they just tracking her?" "Because her tracker reports her in Africa, David. It's malfunctioning. She could be in real danger, and her family is worried." She watched his expression while the news sunk in. He furrowed his brows, and stared intently at his hands. He'd asked if she had made a complaint. Perhaps he'd made an advance and was rebuked? She tried another tack. "David, I sense you're embarrassed about something having to do with this girl. I'm not going to pry if it's a personal matter, but if there's anything you can do to aid in her location, you need to set that aside." "I might be able to help," he conceded, still looking at his hands. "You know where she might have gone?" Scully asked. "No." He took a breath. "But, I might be able to hear her. I, uh, have some particular experience focusing on her 'voice'." His eyes flicked to hers and away again. Scully got the picture. "She likes you?" she asked. "You said you weren't going to pry," he confirmed. She sighed. It was unconscionably invasive behavior, but there were more serious matters at hand. "David, you're fully grown and you don't need me to tell you what's right in this matter." But she did, anyway. "It's not the subject matter that's at issue, it's the willful violation. You know it's wrong to listen in on her private thoughts. If you like her, you should talk to her when she gets back, and if you get to know each other well enough to let her understand what you do, you can ask her permission. Otherwise, this needs to be the last time you do this. I won't mention it again, but I don't think your conscience will let you off as easily." He nodded, abashed. "Alright, then. Is it quiet enough here, or should we go back to the house?" "No, it's ok. I can do it here." He closed his eyes, and worked first on filtering out the disapproval he could still feel radiating from Scully. It was becoming second nature to ignore the background noise of the campus, but he filtered that as well, working on clearing his mind to a perfect silence. Then, slowly, methodically, he began to search for one voice among the static of the world. He couldn't have explained exactly how he did it, how he could find one voice he was looking for, but he knew what he had to do. It seemed to take a very long time, with David sitting silently, a look of deep concentration on his face. The office door opened on the heels of a quick, soft knock, and Jerry let himself in. "Dr. Charles, I'm loo..." She shushed him quickly, and waved him inside, motioning toward David's still form with her head. He padded softly to table by the window, and seated himself in the chair there. "She's really far away," David finally spoke. "And she's... afraid." He pressed his lips together, and squeezed his eyes more tightly shut. "I don't know where she is because she doesn't know where she is. She doesn't remember how she got there." He cocked his head to the side as if listening. "Oh. Oh, she's *terrified*." His breathing quickened as he focused down on the girl's thoughts, trying to understand what was happening through the muddling veil of her fear. "She hears someone coming, now, coming into the room where she is." He felt his heartbeat quicken in sympathy with the girl as he concentrated on what she saw, hoping a visual clue would give away her location. "The door is opening and they're coming in." He gasped. "They're -- AAAAAHH!" David flung himself violently forward from the chair, shocking Scully from her rapt attention to his performance. He fell to the floor, pulling his knees up to his chest and grasping his head. "Stop, stop, stop!!" he screamed. "They're so loud! They're in her head and they're so LOUD!" Scully launched herself from behind the desk and came to her knees on the floor beside David. Grabbing his face in both hands she struggled to make him focus. "David! David, let go! Filter her out, David, close your mind! You know how to do this, David, focus!" "Can't," he wailed, "can't. 'Snot her anymore, I hear them all and they're so LOUD!" He wrenched himself out of her grip, rolling to his knees, his face to the floor like a Muslim in prayer, hands still clasped at his ears. "Stop, stop, stop," he chanted, howling. Tears squeezed from between his clenched lids, and the howl changed to a whimper. "Stop, please, stop." Scully saw with alarm the gush of blood from David's nose, just before he collapsed into unconsciousness. Strong arms lifted him from the floor -- she had forgotten Jerry's presence in the drama of the moment. Now she addressed him in an authoritative voice. "We have to get him to a hospital." "No," Jerry stated, already halfway out the door. "No?!" Scully repeated, incredulous. She half ran to keep up with his fast, long strides. "He's having some sort of seizure! There could be serious brain damage! We need a hospital immediately!" Jerry's pace increased, and now she was actually forced to jog beside him. "Where are you taking him?" she demanded. "He needs care! Are you going to just let him die? I thought you were his friend!" Jerry stopped abruptly, and turned to face her. "A hospital can't help him. I can. But not here. There's no time for this." He resumed his pace, still talking. "He's safe enough while he remains unconscious. Come with us. Your presence can only help him recover. But don't stand in my way." Her decision was instant, and inevitable. "Where?" she asked, jogging alongside. ------------------------------------------------------------- She had found the journey torturous, sick with worry as she was for David's condition. Jerry had simply pushed onward with the quiet focus and determination that was his way. The tubes were the fastest way to get anywhere, and they'd garnered a few strange looks when Jerry hauled his friend aboard, slung over his shoulder. He managed an affable grin at a staring passenger, mumbled something about a party, and propped David up in a seat. The rest of the passengers on the sparsely filled mid-morning tube gradually went back to their own business. They had taken a northeast line that dead-ended in the Appalachian mountains in just under an hour, and Scully was surprised to find that Jerry had an overland transport waiting there. They drove another hour through the mountains into a river valley, and from there Jerry carried David toward a conical hill. It seemed strangely out of place, the diameter stretching at least 150 feet, and the summit rising perhaps 35 feet, on an otherwise level valley floor. When he led the way to a concealed opening in the side of the hill, Scully realized the mound was artificial, and ancient. They crept inside, to a cramped vault in the interior, and there he lay David on the floor, lighting two solar torches out of a bag of supplies he had brought with him from the transport. "Where are we?" Scully asked. "Your people once recognized the places of power on your planet. They didn't understand their significance, but to them they were sacred places. Such people built this place, to take advantage of the power. There is a special peace, here, and recognizing it, they laid their dead to rest in this spot." Scully shook her head, exasperated. "That doesn't tell me anything." "It tells you the only thing that is meaningful. What name do you want? The name before the war? I don't know it. What difference would it make?" He turned back toward David. "I have the ability to heal, if I'm free to concentrate. You must be quiet now." He laid his hands over David's face, his face relaxing into an expression of profound meditation. Scully crawled to David's opposite side, and sitting beside him, comforted herself by holding his hand, fingers wrapped loosely around the strong pulse in his wrist. ------------------------------------------------------------- "Thirsty." David's raspy voice startled Scully from her light doze. "David?" she asked, hopeful. "Thirsty," he repeated. Jerry handed a bottle of water to her out of a pack that he had brought in from the transport. She held David's head up and tipped the bottle to his lips, watching with satisfaction as he drank a deep draught. Thirst slackened, he sagged back onto the ground. "Quiet here," he said, his voice looser for the water. "We're under about 50,000 tons of dirt, David," she said, gesturing to the roof of the vault. "In the hill," she explained. He shook his head at her explanation. "No. Quiet *here*," he emphasized, pointing to his temple. She looked at Jerry. "The 'special peace' of this place?" He nodded. "Voices don't carry, here, into the mind. He can hear us, but no one outside. He will need the silence to heal." "Jerry, what happened to me?" David asked. "You heard the Grays. You weren't prepared. Their telepathy is very strong." "Why haven't I heard them before?" "At first your skill was not sufficient, and they were too far away. But now that you know the sound you will always know it. They will not go back to being silent for you." "I don't think I can stand to hear them again," he moaned, his voice hitching slightly with the vivid memory of recent pain. "I'll teach you to control it," Jerry assured him. "How can you do that?" David responded, dismissively. "You don't know what it's like, having all these voices in your head all the time." "Of course I do, David," Jerry insisted. "Then why don't I ever hear you? I hear everyone else..." He stopped, the obvious conclusion coming only slowly to his muddled thoughts. "Somehow, you block me?" He asked. "I have, until now. You're getting much stronger, though. You were beginning to sense me. I left because I was afraid you might break through when I wasn't controlling myself. I was afraid I might harm you. Listen to me now, David." David pulled himself up to a seated position, leaning his back against the rough, cool wall of the chamber. He gazed steadily at his friend, unsure what to make of the fact that he'd hidden himself and his thoughts, and that he was offering them now. Jerry unshielded the uppermost layer of his consciousness to his friend, thoughts of confidence and reassurance uppermost in his mind. The tickle of a voice in his head was familiar, but David's touch felt different than any he had experienced before. It was to be expected, he supposed. David was another species. He had never communed with a human in this way before. David's face registered the unfamiliarity of Jerry's touch. He was used to being only an eavesdropper, suddenly it was a two way communication, both parties observably aware of the connection of the other. After a moment, he grinned. It wasn't exactly like a conversation. There weren't words, and turns to take. David wondered if the Smiths were all telepathic, and then suddenly the answer was in his head, as though he'd always known it. He knew all at once the experience of the Smiths, that they could not hear a Gray that did not want to be heard, nor ignore one who did. That they could rarely hear humans because they were so faint, but felt a comfort and a kinship in the web of their own voices, always available with the reaching out of a thought. And then Jerry closed himself off, slowly, so that David felt the experience as is he were doing it himself. He emulated the sensation, awkwardly attempting the new skill. "Good," Jerry said aloud. "You're much fainter now." David had been leaning forward in concentration, now he sagged back against the wall. "That was tiring," he said, surprised. "Usually voices just pour into my head, and the only work is just in ignoring them." "There are many facets to this ability you have yet to explore. You've learned a fair amount through your own efforts about filtering voices you do not want to hear, and seeking those you do, but those skills need refinement. And there is more to learn, about broadcasting what you want known, and shielding what you don't. It is instinctual for the Grays, as it is for my people. These lessons in improving control are what would be taught to the young." "Hmm..." David nodded, his eyes slipping shut. Jerry touched him once more, focusing David on his fatigue, encouraging him to surrender to the pull of drowsiness. David yawned hugely, once, and lay back down. To Scully, the events had been surreal. David had awoken, thirsty and agitated, and after a moment's conversation he and Jerry had sat motionless for nearly 30 minutes, staring at one another, with only the occasional facial twitch for her to interpret. A few more words, and David was once again snoring softly. She felt superfluous, and strangely vulnerable. "You should go back," Jerry said. "What, now?" Scully asked, incredulous. "In the morning," Jerry said, shrugging slightly. "Your absence will be noticed." "What about David?" she asked. "He will stay with me." "No." "You can't take him out of here yet. He is weak." "I'm not leaving without him." Jerry turned on her, snapping with the closest thing she had ever seen to anger. "What does it take for you to trust?" he demanded. Her own anger flared. "The truth. Everything you know that you're holding back." "The truth is that he is your last, best, hope. As he is ours. And your absence threatens him." "Why? Why does my absence threaten him? Who is watching me? No one knows who am I, beside you. Are you sure it's not you that I threaten?" she hissed. "What aren't you telling me?" "It is not who you are, but what you do that is watched. There are those that are eager for you to finish your research. If you vanish again they may look for you this time, and if you are here they will find David. And in his case, it is not what he does, but what he is, that matters." He looked over at the sleeping form. "Trust must come before truth. The truth is useless if you lack the trust to believe it." "What does my research have to do with this? Who's watching it? For what purpose?" she demanded. "You already have your own suspicions," Jerry replied. "They are what you will believe, regardless of what I tell you." "The Grays are watching, aren't they? But why? What do they want?" "They want what they wanted before," he answered cryptically. She thought back, peeling through layers of reconstituted memories, to the days of the resistance. "They still want a hybrid? But why?" And then, the swift connection between her abbreviated nightmare and the faculty memo. "That girl. Her tracker placed her in Africa. They abducted her, didn't they?" Finally, the awful realization. "Oh my God. They're using my research to mutilate her, aren't they?" She jumped up, moving as quickly as she could under the low ceiling of the chamber toward the tunnel that led outside. "I have to get back. I have to destroy it." "It's too late for that," Jerry rejected, reaching her easily with an outstretched arm. He pulled gently. "Your research data has already been archived, you know that. No matter how deeply you purge the system, you will not succeed in reclaiming the information from them. That's not the answer." She allowed him to lead her back to the bright circle of the lanterns, sinking slowly back to the floor. "My God," she repeated, "that's what they wanted all along, isn't it? I've felt for years that we've been subtly manipulated, some sciences reinforced while others were encouraged to atrophy. But," she stopped confused. "I'm working from their own information. I got their genome from their own archives. If they want a hybrid, why haven't they just..." she trailed off. "It all becomes clear suddenly, doesn't it?" Jerry asked, sadly. "Because they can't for some reason, can they?" Scully asked. "They don't know how. All those years ago, those men were convinced they were buying time, and saving their families, when really they'd been manipulated into offering exactly the thing the Grays most wanted. All that technology, but--" "But ancient. Failures are extraordinarily rare. Their technology maintains itself. They're inarguably adept at utilizing it, but they've had no need to innovate in millenia." "They're technicians, then, not scientists. But now they're learning again, aren't they? By watching us? I've always wondered what they got out of the reconstruction. You only herd animals that you can exploit," she concluded bitterly. "They are learning, but in this you are still their master. Your vaccine came as a surprise to them, 200 years ago. It was a surprise to all of us." "All of you?" she asked. In response, his face gradually morphed, his features becoming indistinct then solidifying, absent the distinguishing elements of eyes, ears, nose, mouth. Her breath sucked in with a harsh gasp. Just as gradually, he returned to himself. "It's a difficult posture to maintain, voluntarily," he explained, "although it can be made a permanent condition. And ultimately, a fatal one." "The faceless rebels," she asked, "the ones responsible for the burnings, before the wars, they were you?" He nodded. "They were martyrs. As were your victims. We regretted the loss. It was necessary to destroy the hybridization program, to prevent the initiation of colonization." She was surprised by her reaction to the admission. She had expected a resurgence of the horror that sight had once brought, expected to feel anger when finally presented with a face to blame. Instead, she felt resignation, acceptance. Her own efforts during the resistance had caused as many deaths. "It didn't prevent it, though. It only postponed it." "It gave you the opportunity to prepare." "To spread the vaccine," she realized. "But wait, you said our vaccine was a surprise, to all of you." Her precise mind processed the inconsistency. "You couldn't have been buying us time to do something you had no awareness of. If the hybridization program was destroyed, then why was the virus released, in the end?" Jerry refused to meet her eyes, gazing at his feet with something remarkably like shame. "Because you still had a hybrid," was her whispered conclusion. "Cassandra didn't die that day, did she? You took her. And they found out." Where her anger had been absent before, it flared now. "Why? Why didn't you destroy her? Why martyr your people and ours, and then save the one life whose end would have prevented it all?" "Do you know *why* we underwent such mutilations?" he demanded, with the indignity of the unjustly accused. "To prevent infection by the black oil," she stated flatly. "To prevent *re*-infection by the black oil," he corrected, leaning forward into her space, staring intently into her eyes. She stared back at him, defiant, and then she saw it. A thin black film coursing across the surface of his eyes. She gasped, retreating backward, crablike, across the floor, as quickly as possible out of his reach. As she watched, the film once again vanished. "The black oil is part of us. We can't live without it. And yet it enslaves us. It is their will, and when they call upon it, it is agony to resist, and ecstasy to comply. When we are close to death, the oil leaves us at last. Our martyrs were brought to the edge, their faces sealed when the oil escaped, and revived -- to live a short and painful life. You can't know what it's like, to live always with the possibility that your will may one day no longer be your own, the only assurance of your true independence carrying with it an implicit death sentence." Scully's hand crept to the back of her neck, where a scar still covered the spot where the chip had once been that had staved off her cancer, but had also drawn her to one of the burnings. "I think maybe I understand," she conceded, but she didn't move any closer. The chip was long gone. At one time her loneliness had convinced her that even a slow and agonizing death by cancer was preferable to her interminable life, and she had removed it. There had been no effect. "Humans live without the oil," he continued. "And when they control you through the oil, it never stays in you for long. We always believed it was because it can't. That somehow you're toxic to them. They wanted a hybrid, to make you more like us, able to be enslaved. We wanted a hybrid so that we could learn the opposite lesson. To become more like you. Free. That's why we kept Cassandra." He dropped his voice. "When they discovered we had her, they launched a war against us to recover her, and released the virus. We destroyed her, in the end, when it became clear it was the only way to halt both offensives. We destroyed their plans, forcing them to start from scratch. We destroyed our own as well." "And now it's all beginning again," Scully said. She had far too many lifetimes of fatigue for this battle. "Your salvation came from the same source as your destruction, last time. It will again," he said with assurance. "The Gray's genome," Scully said. Jerry nodded. "Whatever they have learned from you, you are still the more adept at science, at insight. You mustn't stop now. It is a race." David sighed in his sleep, and rolled toward the wall, presenting them with his back. "What about him?" Scully asked. "Where does he fit in?" "His telepathy is unlike any others," Jerry explained. "He hears, without being heard." "I don't understand," Scully complained. "What does that mean?" Jerry shifted, trying to conjure a way to explain. How do you explain color to someone without sight? "Our telepathy is such that you can't really listen to another without the other being aware of it, on some level. Even when we're not actively listening, we're aware of the web of minds touching ours. We can't," he searched for the word, "we can't eavesdrop. David can. And he hears with great strength and at great distance. To use a metaphor, in a world of radios, he is Arecibo." "Is it dangerous for him?" she asked. "Mulder almost died from something like this." "Mulder also stood to develop an astonishing telepathy. He could have been taught to control it, if he'd been brought someplace like this, in time. It was out of the question, though. The times were treacherous, and too many were aware of him. We couldn't go to him. David, though, has not been noticed. I can stay here safely, and teach him. When the time is right, he will hear them, and know what to do." "What about the oil in you? Will it infect him?" "I am vanished to my masters while we are in the mound. They cannot hear or control me if I stay inside. He is safe. Besides, you vaccinated him yourself, didn't you?" She nodded, no longer surprised by anything Jerry might have guessed. "I can never leave this place again," Jerry added. "You will be in each other's hands exclusively once he leaves here." "Why can't you leave?" "Those of us who have been allowed some freedom to live among you, as we wish, do so at a cost of keeping our enslavement a secret. I have forfeit my freedom by telling you these truths. If I were to leave, my knowledge of my transgression would endanger you, and my knowledge of David's condition would endanger him." He smiled sadly. "I still prefer a prison of my own making." "If your knowledge is a danger to David, isn't mine as well? You said the Grays are watching me, watching my research. Are they listening to me, too?" "They may be." "Then I can't go back either." "You can't stay here. If they want to find you eventually they will. Even without a tracker." "Then we have a problem, don't we." "There is another solution," Jerry offered. "What?" "Have I told you enough now, to earn your trust?" he asked. She didn't answer immediately. Jerry had been surprisingly insightful when he said that trust necessarily had to come before truth. He'd told her an enormous amount, filled in gaps in her understanding of the wars, and the Grays' subsequent behavior that had bothered her for years. And yet, he offered no proof beyond his word. She and Mulder had been in this situation too many times to count. They had both made mistakes about when to trust a source and believe his information. Such mistakes had often cost them dearly. So the question wasn't really whether Jerry had told her enough to earn her trust, but whether he had earned her trust enough for her to believe him. Melissa would have told her to listen to her gut. She considered his gift to her, that night at David's grandmother's house. She considered his self-elected exile, if it were to be believed. She recalled their interactions over the previous year, the games of baseball in the backyard, the quiet way he had watched out for herself and David. Everything he had done, every advantage he hadn't taken could be construed as a manipulation, calculated to earn an undeserved trust. Or she could reject the paranoia and take his actions at face value. 'Missy,' she thought, 'what would you do?' The silence stretched on. At last, just as Jerry's face began to fall in defeat she whispered, "Yes." "Then trust me now," he pleaded. "In the morning, before you leave, I'll take these memories away from you. I can make you forget, about what I told you, about the full nature of David's skill. I'll give you different memories of tonight instead. Safe ones. You'll be no threat to him then, or to yourself." She felt a thrill of dread at allowing such an intrusion. "How can I be any use to him, either, without the things you've told me tonight?" "The Grays' part in the girl's disappearance you realized yourself. You will again, because your experience can lead you to no other conclusion. The rest of it, David will know himself. But he'll have the capacity to shield his thoughts, I'll teach him. He'll learn what you need to do, and he'll be the one to guide you." She considered her options, concluded that she had none. "Ok. But before you make me forget, I want to hear you tell David what you told me. And I want him to watch while you do this, to know what you're doing. Then I'll go back." Jerry nodded, accepting the conditions. They waited out the night together, but only David slept.